Nope, that’s not a fantastic claim about how fast the Dodecahedron Books produces books, publishes books or even reads books. Granted, some Indie writers are pretty prolific, but even the speediest of them will never get to that rate. Maybe someday an Artificial Intelligence (A.I.) might do it – anyway, that could be the basis for a Science Fiction story. Novel writing reaches The Singularity.
That’s probably pretty close to the rate at which new books appear on Amazon though. There are about 525,000 minutes in a year, so Amazon probably does put up at least a book a minute.
But what I am really writing about, is the rate at which Chapters (Canada’s biggest bookstore chain) sells books, on average, in one of its big box bookstores. (I mention Chapters, but the same reasoning should apply to Barnes and Noble in the U.S. or Waterstones in the U.K.). The calculation follows:
- In its Q3 2014 report (released in Feb 2015 on their website, page 31), it reports $459 million in “Print” revenues, for the first three quarters. We will estimate that Q4 will be similar to Q1 and Q2. That was about $250 million for Q1 and Q2 combined, so call it $125 million each. So, we will add that much to the $459 million, coming to an annual forecast of about $585 million.
- That figure includes magazines, newspapers and calendars, so let’s estimate those to make up about 10 percent of the total. That brings the amount for books to about $526 million.
- Chapters has 91 superstores and 130 small format stores (page 3 of the same report). Let’s assume that a small format store is about 25 percent the size of a superstore, giving a total of 117 superstore equivalents.
- We divide print sales into the number of stores, giving about $5.0 million per store, per year.
- So, that’s about $14,000 per day, per superstore.
- If we assume that a store is open 16 hours per day, on average, that gives 850 print sales per hour.
- If we assume the average print book is about $15, then that gives us about 60 books per hour, or one book per minute.
Chapters requires a lot of infrastructure to sell that one book per minute in each of its stores. Those stores are big, so the leases must be significant.
They also require a fair number of staff to sell that book per minute. In the report mentioned above, they state that wages and benefits for staff came to about $141 million in the first 3 quarters of fiscal 2014. Running through similar calculations, I estimate that each store must pay out about $3500 per day in wages. That would imply about a dozen staff members in the store, at any given time, assuming an average pay of $20 per hour.
Contrast all that to downloading a book onto a Kindle or Kobo, a one-click operation that transfers information almost instantaneously to the customer and for pennies per transaction, at most. Granted, Amazon must spend a lot on its computer system, but it seems clear that there is at least an order of magnitude difference in efficiency, between the two processes, with the advantage going to the ebook.
It will be interesting to continue to watch the competition between the two modalities play out. Perhaps it will end up at The Singularity, after all.
And here’s a vaguely related comic, that mentions The Singularity.